I routinely get asked by friends and family which SmartPhone they should pick up. This is always a difficult discussion as the Smart Phone industry of today, similar to the PC industry of the early 2000′s, is changing rapidly almost daily. I’ve decided to start a post that I will maintain – though I’m unsure of update frequency at this point – that provides some basic information on which phones are the absolute best on the four major US carriers. I’m not going to look at mid-range, free phones, etc. If you’re still interested, read on.
Few assumptions: You know what platform you are interested in, with the exception of the iPhone, you should be well aware of what you are getting yourself into. If you’re not, you’ll be finding yourself dealing with returns and exchanges at the often crowded Wireless stores(except Sprint’s).
AT&T Wireless
iPhone. No further discussion required until they release multiple models. The iPhone 4 is the current model and will be replaced in September with a 4S/5 model. This is usually my first recommendation to people who aren’t technically savvy or don’t want to tinker with their phone.
NOTE: Jail-breaking your iPhone and running apps from Cyndia doesn’t mean you are technically savvy. A 2nd grader with Google can figure that out.
Winner: iPhone 4, the 3GS is cheap, but why buy Ford Festiva when you really want the Ford Raptor.
Android. AT&T offers a handful of current top-of-the-line Android handsets. You are essentially left deciding which User Interface(UI) you want to deal with for the next two years of your life. The three phones are the HTC Inspire 4G, MOTOROLA ATRIX 4G, and Samsung Infuse 4G. None of these handsets are truly 4G but that’s another post someday. Of the three, I would recommend the overall ‘best’ selection to the ATRIX. It has the right size mated with excellent hardware. I would rate the UI 2nd to the HTC Inpire. Most power users don’t care about the UI though because they are installing custom ROMS anyways.
Winner: MOTO ATRIX(Don’t waste your money on the laptop dock, no really don’t). If you can sacrifice a bit of hardware performance, the Nexus S which was made available yesterday, July 26th, is a strong choice.
Windows Phone. Samsung Focus, HTC Surround, LG Quantum, and HTC HD7S. All devices are essentially running 1+ year old hardware. Thumbs up to Samsung for having the best screen of the bunch.
Winner: Samsung Focus for being the best of the worst.
BlackBerry. Not sure why I would include this platform, but hey someone might care. Ah BlackBerry you used to be so good and AT&T was/is one of the best partners. A whole slew of device refreshes – read: small hardware changes are coming down in the next 6 months.
Winner: BlackBerry Torch 9800. If sliders aren’t for you as they aren’t for many, the two year old Bold 9700 should catch your eye until the previously mentioned refresh occurs.
Sprint
iPhone. Not available, sorry.
Winner: Not Sprint Customers – yet.
Android. Sprint likes Android, unfortunately not enough to maintain a large high-end selection of Phones. You have a mashup of last year’s hardware with gimmicky 3D cameras.
Winner: Nexus S 4G. If you want a fancy UI, the HTC EVO 3D would be a runner up.
Windows Phone. Not much to say here, they have one HTC Arrive.
Winner: HTC Arrive, winner by disqualification.
BlackBerry. RIM has yet to embrace 4G tech such as Sprint’s WiMAX so the CDMA compatible BlackBerry family is severally slim. Sprint has a handful of low-end BlackBerry devices and a single “high-end BlackBerry” device in their line-up.
Winner: BlackBerry Bold 9650. I’m bored.
T-Mobile
iPhone. Not available, well until AT&T completes their purposed acquisition next year. You can get your iPhone working with T-Mobile’s EDGE(2.5G) service but it won’t work with their 3G network or their 3G network marketed as “4G” network
Winner: Slow performing data iPhones.
Android. T-Mobile was the first carrier to launch an Android phone with the awkward G1. Today they have the largest Android selection, albeit more mid-range focused. Recently TMo has been launching higher end phones, namely the recently launched HTC Senation 4G which packs some of the fastest hardware on current Android phones across any carrier.
Winner: HTC Sensation 4G.
Windows Phone. Not much to say here, they have one HTC HD7.
Winner: HTC HD7, winner by disqualification.
BlackBerry. TMo has a very limited BlackBerry offering, two models in fact.
Winner: BlackBerry Bold 9870. I’m really bored.
Verizon Wireless
iPhone. iPhone 4, just get it.
Winner: iPhone 4, the one and only Verizon iPhone.
Android. Verizon has the largest selection of higher end Android phones. Verizon went bawls to the wall in November of 2009 with Android and their launch of the original Motorla DROID. A hugely successful phone. This spawned the Verizon DROID product family. It’s funny because their marketing worked so well, you often hear people refer to their T-Mobile Samsung Android phone as a ‘DROID”. Since 4G is all the rage these days and Verizon has launched the largest actual 4G network, I’ll focus my recommendation there.
Winner: DROID CHARGE by Samsung. Will be displaced in two weeks by the DROID BIONIC.
Windows Phone. Not much to say here, they have one, the HTC Trophy. Probably one of the better Windows Phone 7 devices out there.
Winner: HTCTrophy, winner by disqualification.
BlackBerry. Verizon has the 2nd best BlackBerry offering.
Winner: BlackBerry Bold 9650. I’m asleep.